Fractional CMO Chief Outsiders: Agency Model vs. Independent Leadership

Chief Outsiders is one of the biggest names in the fractional CMO space. And if you’re researching how to hire a fractional CMO, their name will come up. But just because they’re big doesn’t mean they’re the right fit for every business.
Here’s a breakdown of what Chief Outsiders offers, how it compares to hiring an independent CMO, and how to decide what’s best for your business.
What Is Chief Outsiders?
Chief Outsiders is a national agency that provides part-time CMOs to companies that need strategic marketing leadership. They match clients with one of their vetted CMOs and provide an agency structure for onboarding and support.
You get:
- A match with one of their consultants
- Back-end support from their agency
- Access to a wide network of C-level marketing leaders
Sounds great. But let’s look closer.
Pros of Hiring Through Chief Outsiders
- Established process: They’ve done this hundreds of times and bring polish to the experience.
- Credibility: CMOs in their network often have enterprise-level experience.
- Structure: Onboarding, reporting, and communication are handled by the agency.
Cons to Consider
- Higher cost: You’re paying for agency overhead, not just the CMO.
- Less flexibility: Packages and scope can be rigid.
- Limited control: You don’t choose your CMO—they match you.
Independent Fractional CMOs: What’s Different?
An independent CMO works directly with you. No middle agency. Just one leader, one strategy, and one line of communication.
Pros:
- Personalized attention
- Direct access to the strategist
- Lower overhead and more flexibility
Cons:
- Less support staff
- May need your existing team to execute
Which One’s Right for You?
Choose Chief Outsiders if:
- You want a plug-and-play experience with high-level structure
- You need quick replacement or backup support
- You have a larger budget and want access to multiple experts
Choose Independent if:
- You value custom strategy and deeper collaboration
- You already have a team to implement
- You want direct leadership without added layers
Client Experience: Real Talk
One of our clients interviewed with Chief Outsiders and an independent CMO. Chief Outsiders pitched a team. The independent CMO offered a transformation.
Guess who they hired?
The client chose the independent. They wanted a relationship, not just a resource.
Final Thought: Buy Strategy, Not Just a Logo
Chief Outsiders is a solid option—but the best choice is the one that aligns with your business stage, your leadership style, and your goals.
Book a discovery call and find out how a strategic partner could unlock your next level of growth.
Explore Coaching with Lisa Benson
Book a Clarity Call
Start with the 9-Line Business Roadmap