Stop Guessing: How to Create Content Your Audience Actually Craves

You’ve been at this for a while now. Posting consistently. Showing up. Trying the hooks, the hashtags, the trending audios. You’re doing everything the gurus told you to do, and yet your content still feels like it’s landing in an empty room.

You check the analytics, and it’s crickets. Maybe a few likes from your mom and that one supportive friend who comments on everything. But the people you actually want to reach? The ones who would pay you good money for your coaching? They’re scrolling right past.

Here’s what nobody tells you: the problem isn’t your posting frequency. It’s not your graphics. It’s not even the algorithm. The problem is that you’re guessing. You’re throwing spaghetti at the wall and hoping something sticks, when what you really need is messaging clarity that makes your ideal clients stop mid-scroll and think, “Wait, she’s talking directly to me.”

Let’s fix that.

The Exhausting Cycle of Content Confusion

You know the feeling. You sit down to create content for the week, and suddenly your brain goes blank. What do I even talk about? You end up recycling the same tips everyone else is sharing, or worse, you post something generic just to check the box and stay “visible.”

Then you watch other coaches in your space, people with similar offers, similar experience, absolutely crushing it. Their posts get engagement. Their DMs are full. And you’re left wondering what secret ingredient you’re missing.

Here’s the truth that might sting a little: the best content for coaches isn’t about being the smartest or the most polished. It’s about being the most understood. The coaches who are winning right now aren’t necessarily better than you. They’ve just figured out how to create content your audience actually wants, content that speaks to the exact conversation already happening in their ideal client’s head.

And that starts with getting radically clear on what your people actually crave.

Your Audience Doesn’t Want What You Think They Want

Here’s where most coaches get it wrong. They assume their audience wants information. Tips. Strategies. How-to content packed with value.

And yes, those things matter. But they’re not what makes someone stop scrolling, save your post, and slide into your DMs ready to work with you.

What your audience actually craves is to feel seen. They want to know that someone out there gets it. Gets them. Understands the specific, nuanced struggle they’re facing at 2 AM when they’re wondering if this whole coaching thing is even going to work.

Content that converts clients doesn’t just educate: it resonates. It names the thing they haven’t been able to articulate. It validates the frustration they’ve been feeling. It gives language to the transformation they desperately want but don’t know how to ask for.

This is the difference between content that gets a polite like and content that gets a “How do I work with you?”

When you understand your audience’s deep needs: not just their surface-level problems, but the emotional weight underneath: your content becomes magnetic. It becomes unmissable.

The Unmissable Secret: It’s Not Just What You Say, It’s How You Say It

You’ve probably heard that you need to “niche down” or “speak to your ideal client.” But here’s where that advice falls short: most coaches interpret this as narrowing their topic or service. They think messaging clarity means being more specific about what they offer.

But being unmissable isn’t about what you offer. It’s about what you say and how you say it.

Two coaches can teach the exact same thing: let’s say, how to sign clients on Instagram: and one will build a waitlist while the other struggles to fill a discovery call. The difference? The first coach has figured out how to articulate her message in a way that lands. She’s not just sharing information. She’s speaking her audience’s language. She’s naming their specific pain. She’s painting a picture of the transformation in a way that feels tangible and urgent.

This is the “Unmissable” secret that changes everything: your message is your magnet. When you get crystal clear on what you’re really saying: and why it matters to the specific person you’re trying to reach: your content stops being noise and starts being a beacon.

So how do you actually get there?

Stop Guessing and Start Listening

The fastest path to how to create content your audience actually wants isn’t sitting in a room brainstorming clever ideas. It’s getting out of your own head and into theirs.

Start by looking at what’s already working. Go back through your existing content and identify the posts that actually got engagement. Not vanity metrics, but real engagement: comments, DMs, saves, shares. What did those posts have in common? What topic did you cover? What emotion did you tap into? What specific pain point did you name?

Most coaches never do this analysis. They’re too busy creating the next piece of content to study what’s already resonating. But this is where the gold is. Your audience is already telling you what they want: you just have to pay attention.

Then, get curious about the conversations happening around you. What are people in your space complaining about? What questions come up again and again in your DMs, on discovery calls, in Facebook groups? What are your competitors talking about that seems to land? Not so you can copy them, but so you can understand the conversation your audience is already having.

The goal is to stop guessing what they want to hear and start speaking directly to what they’re already thinking.

From Random Posting to Intentional Messaging

Here’s the shift that separates coaches who struggle with content from coaches who use content to build thriving businesses: intentionality.

Random posting is exhausting. It’s the content hamster wheel that leaves you burnt out and wondering why none of this is working. Intentional messaging, on the other hand, is strategic. Every piece of content has a purpose. Every post is designed to move your ideal client closer to working

This doesn’t mean you need a complicated content system or a 47-step strategy. It means you need clarity on three things: who you’re talking to, what transformation you’re offering, and how you’re going to articulate that in a way that makes them feel something.

When you have that clarity, content creation becomes easier. You’re not staring at a blank screen wondering what to post. You know exactly what your people need to hear, and you have a hundred different ways to say it. You can show up consistently without burning out because you’re not reinventing the wheel every single time.

This is what it looks like to create content that converts clients: not through manipulation or hype, but through genuine connection and messaging that lands.

Your Next Move

If you’ve been posting and praying, hoping that eventually something will click, it’s time for a different approach. The coaches who are building real momentum right now aren’t working harder than you. They’re just more intentional about their message.

Get clear on your audience’s deep needs. Not just what they say they want, but what’s keeping them up at night. What frustration are they carrying? What transformation would change everything for them?

Study what’s already working. Look at your own content, look at what’s resonating in your space, and use that data to inform what you create next.

Focus on how you say it. Your message is your magnet. The way you articulate your value: the specific words, the emotional resonance, the clarity: is what makes you unmissable.

You don’t need to post more. You need to post with purpose. And when you do, everything shifts.

If you’re ready to dive deeper into building a content strategy that actually works for coaches, that’s exactly what we help you do at DeBella DeBall Designs. Because you didn’t start this business to spend all your time creating content that nobody sees. You started it to make an impact. Let’s make sure your message actually lands.

Ready to build the kind of authority that attracts premium clients naturally?

Let’s work together to create your organic authority-building strategy that gets you known as the go-to expert in your field: no ad spend required.

If you’re done with trial and error and ready to build with proven frameworks and strategic guidance, here’s what’s next:

Book a Clarity Call with Lisa Benson. Let’s map out your next 90 days with tactical strategy, not theory. We’ll look at where you are, where you want to go, and exactly what needs to happen to get there.

Start with the 9-Line Business Roadmap. Get the framework that helps women service providers scale to consistent $5K-$15K months without burning out or sacrificing boundaries.

Learn About Operation Six-Figure. Our signature coaching system installs repeatable systems for growth—so you can lead like a CEO instead of a scrappy solopreneur barely keeping up.