How to Build an Email List from Scratch
(Even If You Have 0 Subscribers)
Start Your Email List from Scratch: A Guide for Coaches & Service Providers
You don’t need a massive following to create impact. What you need is ownership—a way to directly connect with your people without relying on social media’s ever-changing rules. That’s where email marketing steps in. If you’re a coach, consultant, or small business owner trying to scale, building an email list from scratch might be your smartest next move.
Let’s walk through exactly how to do it—without fluff, filler, or a pre-existing audience.
Why Email Lists Still Matter in 2024
Even with DMs, TikToks, and Stories taking over, email marketing is still one of the highest-converting digital marketing channels available. According to HubSpot, the average ROI for email marketing is $42 for every $1 spent.
But more than stats, email is the only platform you actually own. Unlike social media, where your reach can tank overnight due to algorithm shifts, your email list gives you direct access to your audience. And for coaches or service providers, that access translates into trust, connection, and revenue.
Step 1: Know Who You’re Talking To
Before collecting emails, you need to get clear on who you’re serving. If you’re helping new coaches or burnt-out service providers, speak directly to their pain points. Use tools like:
- Meta Audience Insights
- Google Analytics
- Conversations from your DMs or Facebook group
This clarity helps you shape offers and content that feel like a “yes” from the start.
Step 2: Create a Lead Magnet They’ll Actually Want
Don’t just promise “value.” Deliver something they can use immediately:
- A one-page roadmap (like our Mission Start 9-Line Plan)
- A quick win checklist for client attraction
- A script or template they’d normally pay for
Use clear, benefit-driven headlines:
“Attract 3 New Clients in 7 Days (Without Ads)” will convert far better than “Free eBook.”
And remember: presentation matters. Tools like Canva or DeBella DeBall Designs’ branding services can elevate your freebie from basic to binge-worthy.
Step 3: Make Sign-Up Effortless
Embed opt-in forms across your site:
- On your homepage
- As a pop-up
- Within blog posts like this one
- On your services page
Use friendly language. Instead of “Subscribe now,” try:
- “Get instant access”
- “Send me the roadmap”
- “Join the 6-Figure Success List”
Make sure forms are mobile-friendly, use double opt-in, and confirm delivery with a clean welcome email.
Step 4: Promote It Like You Mean It
It’s not enough to build it—you have to share it:
- Pin it to the top of your Instagram or LinkedIn
- Mention it in podcast interviews or guest blogs
- Add it to your email signature
- Partner with aligned brands for cross-promotion
You can even create a simple landing page to drive ad traffic or use GHL (Go HighLevel) automations to handle nurturing.
Step 5: Deliver. Delight. Repeat.
A welcome sequence isn’t just a polite hello—it’s your chance to set the tone. Use it to:
- Reintroduce yourself
- Share a story or value-based post
- Offer one small, immediate win
- Invite them to your Facebook group
Then show up regularly. Weekly or bi-weekly newsletters, exclusive updates, or even client spotlights. Don’t ghost your list—you worked hard for it.
Want inspiration? See how Mailchimp or ConvertKit approach onboarding. Then tailor it to fit your voice.
Final Thoughts: You Don’t Need Big Numbers—You Need the Right People
Too many new entrepreneurs focus on vanity metrics. But an email list of 100 buyers beats 10,000 followers who never engage. Start simple. Offer value. Stay consistent.
And if you need help crafting a system that doesn’t just grow your list—but drives revenue—we build marketing systems for service providers that scale with clarity.
Explore Coaching with Lisa Benson
Book a Clarity Call
Start with the 9-Line Business Roadmap